File 04Season one
Who sold you life insurance?
How a bet on death became a father's duty
The short answer
In the 1840s many Americans saw life insurance as a bet on death. Insurers changed that by changing the pitch. They stopped selling money and started selling duty, and famous preachers told men that providing for a family was every man's duty. In about thirty years, the insurance in force grew from under $5 million to about $2 billion.
- Where
- The United States
- The objection
- A wager on a life
- The new pitch
- A good father's duty
- A famous voice
- Henry Ward Beecher, in print by 1866
- The growth
- Under $5 million in 1840, about $2 billion by the early 1870s
A bet on death
When life insurance spread in America in the 1840s, a lot of people found it distasteful. The sociologist Viviana Zelizer, whose history of the industry is the main source here, found that the insured were seen as "betting" with their lives against the company. A widow's payout looked suspiciously like the proceeds of a winning lottery ticket.
There was fear in it too. An insurer's own booklet from 1867 lists the objections wives gave, among them the worry that a man who took a policy would be brought home dead the next day. In 1869 another company's newsletter wrote of "the mysterious connection between insuring life and losing life".
From money to duty
So the companies changed what they talked about. Beginning in the 1830s, as Virginia Postrel sums up Zelizer's work, insurers largely abandoned arguments about finances in favour of piety, sentiment, altruism and paternal responsibility. Life insurance came to be counted among the duties of a good and responsible father.
Clergymen helped. Henry Ward Beecher, the celebrity preacher of his day, put it in a sentence that was in print by 1866: "It is every man's duty to provide for his family." No source we read says he was paid by an insurer, and we do not say so.
Agents, pamphlets and guilt
The message travelled through advertisements, editorials, pamphlets and soliciting agents. In the insurance writing of the period, as quoted by Zelizer, a man who refused a policy showed his selfishness, since he was willing to leave a helpless widow and destitute children behind.
The numbers
In 1840 the total life insurance in force in the United States was estimated at under $5 million. By the early 1870s it had reached about $2 billion.
This is a story about how something was sold. It is not advice on whether to buy life insurance.
Otis saysProtecting your family is love. The guilt if you don't was sold to you.
The dates
- 1840Life insurance in force in the United States is estimated at under $5 million.
- 1840sMutual companies spread, and with them advertisements, pamphlets and soliciting agents.
- 1866The Atlantic Monthly prints Henry Ward Beecher's line that it is every man's duty to provide for his family.
- 1867An insurer's booklet lists wives' fears that a policy tempts fate.
- Early 1870sInsurance in force reaches about $2 billion.
What the record does not say
Things often repeated about this story that the sources do not support, and where our own film is careful.
- No source shows that Beecher was paid by an insurance company. He was one of many clergymen who endorsed it.
- The churches did not ban life insurance. The historian Sharon Ann Murphy calls the clerical opposition exaggerated, and clergy were among the early customers.
- Life insurance existed before 1840. About $600,000 was in force in 1830. It was small, not absent.
- The peak of about $2 billion is dated 1870 in one place and 1871 in another, so we say the early 1870s.
Questions people ask
Was life insurance once considered immoral?
Yes. In nineteenth century America many people saw it as a wager on a life. Zelizer found that the insured were seen as "betting" with their lives against the company, and The Atlantic Monthly wrote in 1866 that objection was continually made that it was of the nature of a wager.
How did life insurance become popular in America?
Insurers moved their pitch from money to duty, backed by prominent clergymen, pamphlets and sales agents. The insurance in force went from under $5 million in 1840 to about $2 billion in the early 1870s.
What did Henry Ward Beecher say about life insurance?
By 1866 he was in print saying "It is every man's duty to provide for his family." In 1870 he asked whether a Christian man could justify himself in neglecting such a duty.
Sources
- Viviana Zelizer, "Human Values and the Market: The Case of Life Insurance and Death in 19th-Century America", American Journal of Sociology 84(3), 1978, read through Timothy Taylor, Conversable Economist, 2017. Read it
- Virginia Postrel, "When Buying Life Insurance Was Deemed Immoral", Reason, 2017. Read it
- Livia Gershon, "Putting a Price on a Life", JSTOR Daily, 2016. Read it
- "Life Assurance", The Atlantic Monthly, September 1866. Read it
- Sharon Ann Murphy, "Life Insurance in the United States through World War I", EH.Net Encyclopedia. Read it
- Haeffele and Carges, "Viviana Zelizer: Relational Exchange and Association", The Independent Review 28(2), 2023. Read it
A dramatisation based on Viviana Zelizer's history of American life insurance (1978, 1979), The Atlantic Monthly (1866) and Sharon Ann Murphy's history of the industry. The preacher's line is his printed words of 1866, read by an actor. Every character is an animal; no real person is shown.
Think we have a fact wrong? Write to [email protected] with what you have found. We check every message and we correct mistakes.



