Otis, the raccoon host of The Otis FilesTHE OTIS FILES

Home / Files / File 05

File 05Season one

Who sold you Father's Day?

The menswear stores behind the gifts

By The Otis Files. Published .

Cover of the film: Who sold you Father's Day?
Opens Wednesday 25 November, 3 PM Eastern

Subscribe on YouTube to catch it

The short answer

The day itself began with a daughter. In 1910 in Spokane, Sonora Dodd asked for one day to honour the father who had raised six children alone. The shopping came later. In the late 1930s New York's menswear retailers formed a council to promote the day, and sales agents called it "a second Christmas". In 2026 Americans planned to spend a record $27.9 billion on it.

Spokane's first Father's Day
19 June 1910
Who asked for it
Sonora Smart Dodd
Who sold it
Menswear retailers, from the late 1930s
Made permanent
1972
Planned spending, 2026
$27.9 billion

A daughter's idea

Sonora Dodd's father, William Jackson Smart, was a Civil War veteran and a single parent who raised his six children in Spokane, Washington. After hearing a Mother's Day sermon in 1909, she proposed a day for fathers to the city's ministers.

On 19 June 1910 Spokane held its celebration. At Dodd's church, girls handed out red roses to honour living fathers and white roses for fathers who had died.

Years of jokes

The idea was not an easy sell. Newspapers frequently ran cynical and sarcastic attacks and jokes about it. Men, as one history puts it, scoffed at the holiday's sentimental attempts to domesticate manliness with flowers and gift-giving.

The retailers step in

What changed it was the trade. In the late 1930s New York's menswear retailers formed a council to promote Father's Day, and retailers worked to make the day into "a second Christmas", as sales agents called it. A newspaper in 1938 described the result: neckties, shirts, socks, pipes, tobacco, golf clubs and other gifts showering upon the fathers of America.

Then came the war. The national marketing slogan for the holiday in 1942 was "Father, the Defender of the Home", and advertisers argued that celebrating Father's Day was a way to honour American troops. In June 1942 the National Father's Day Committee named General Douglas MacArthur Father of the Year.

A law, then a very large bill

On 24 April 1972 President Richard Nixon signed the law that fixed Father's Day on the third Sunday in June. In 2026 the National Retail Federation expected spending on the day to reach a record $27.9 billion.

Otis saysThe thank-you is yours. The shopping list was sold to you.

The dates

  1. 1909Sonora Dodd hears a Mother's Day sermon and proposes a day for fathers.
  2. 1910Spokane celebrates Father's Day on 19 June. Girls hand out roses at Dodd's church.
  3. Late 1930sNew York's menswear retailers form a council to promote the day.
  4. 1942The slogan is "Father, the Defender of the Home". General MacArthur is named Father of the Year.
  5. 1972President Nixon signs the law fixing the third Sunday in June.
  6. 2026Americans plan to spend a record $27.9 billion.

What the record does not say

Things often repeated about this story that the sources do not support, and where our own film is careful.

  • Spokane in 1910 was not the first Father's Day service ever held. Fairmont, West Virginia held one on 5 July 1908.
  • Sonora Dodd was not a victim of the shops. She welcomed the gifts. In 1965 she said, "I do not think any gift too great for fathers."
  • The retailers' council goes by different names and founding years in different sources, so we say only the late 1930s.
  • The $27.9 billion is a survey forecast of planned spending, not a count of sales.

Questions people ask

Who invented Father's Day?

Sonora Smart Dodd of Spokane, Washington proposed a day for fathers after a Mother's Day sermon in 1909, and Spokane celebrated it on 19 June 1910. An earlier service was held in Fairmont, West Virginia in 1908.

When did Father's Day become an official holiday?

In 1972, when President Nixon signed a law designating the third Sunday in June as Father's Day.

Why do people give gifts on Father's Day?

Menswear retailers promoted the day from the late 1930s, and their sales agents called it "a second Christmas". A 1938 newspaper already listed neckties, shirts, socks and pipes among the gifts.

Sources

  1. Kyle Melnick, The Washington Post, reprinted in The Spokesman-Review, 12 June 2025. Read it
  2. Jonathan Zimmerman, "Father's Day for sale", WHYY, 2015. Read it
  3. Gil Troy, "The Man Who Made Father's Day a Cash Cow", The Daily Beast. Read it
  4. HISTORY.com, "Father's Day". Read it
  5. US House of Representatives, History, Art and Archives, "Father's Day Becomes a National Holiday". Read it
  6. National Retail Federation, "Father's Day Spending to Hit Record $27.9 Billion", 2026. Read it
  7. Wikipedia, "Father's Day (United States)". Read it
  8. GenealogyBank, on the 1942 Father of the Year, 2015. Read it

A dramatisation based on the Washington Post's 2025 account of Sonora Smart Dodd, Jonathan Zimmerman (WHYY, 2015), Gil Troy (The Daily Beast), HISTORY.com, the US House history office and the National Retail Federation (2026). The 1942 slogan is printed marketing copy, read by an actor. Every character is an animal; no real person is shown.

Think we have a fact wrong? Write to [email protected] with what you have found. We check every message and we correct mistakes.

Watch the film

About a minute long, on every platform.

বাংলায় দেখুন

বাবা দিবসে উপহার দিতেই হবে? বুদ্ধিটা কার?